Should Xero invoice reminders go to all contacts in one email, or separate emails?

Does Xero send invoice reminders to all contacts in the same email?

Xero sends each invoice reminder to the primary person on the customer record and to every additional person who has "Include in emails" ticked, and that is the whole of the control. There is no setting that says "one email with everyone on it" or "a separate email to each person", and the body of the email cannot greet each recipient by name. You get whatever the contact flags produce.

Take a customer with three contacts: Maya in accounts payable, Tom the office manager and Sarah the CEO. When a reminder fires, either all three sit on one To line and see each other's replies, or each gets a separate email greeting them by name. Xero lets you choose neither.

When should all contacts get one shared reminder email?

One shared email, with every contact on the To line, is the right pattern when several people at the customer genuinely need to see payment status and each other's replies. It is the default most SMB-to-SMB teams settle on. It works when:

• Multiple people need visibility. If accounts payable, the office manager and the GM are all expected to know where an invoice stands, one shared thread keeps them aligned.
• Replies should be visible to everyone. Maya saying "scheduling for Friday" is more useful when Tom and Sarah see it too.
• The customer relationship is flat. Small businesses, founder-owner teams, anywhere there is no strict need-to-know hierarchy.

The downside: senior contacts can feel exposed when their inbox fills with reminders meant for the AP team. Pair the shared email with the "Only send to primary contact" toggle for early reminders if you want to protect those relationships.

When should each contact get a separate reminder email?

Separate emails, one per contact and each greeting its recipient by name, are the right pattern for bigger or more formal customers, where each finance contact handles their own invoices and a mass To line reads as sloppy. It works when:

• The customer is larger or more formal. Each finance contact owns a portfolio of invoices and expects to be addressed directly.
• Personalisation matters. "Hi Maya" reads better than "Hi all".
• Contacts should not see each other. Useful for distributors and resellers where contacts sit on different teams or sites.

The downside: if Maya and Tom both reply, you can end up running two parallel threads about one invoice. Match separate emails with a clear owner of the invoice on your side, replying through one consolidated thread.

How to choose one email or separate emails in Paidnice

Paidnice controls the audience with two toggles under Settings → Email Preferences → General Email Settings, and they apply to the reminders and statements Paidnice sends from your Xero data. Late-fee notices and payment-plan notices are separate and are not controlled by these two toggles.

• Only send to primary contact. Overrides everything else. When on, Paidnice emails the primary contact and ignores the rest.
• Include all contact persons in same email. Controls how multiple contacts are addressed when the first toggle is off. On is one email with all contacts on the To line. Off is a separate email per contact, with that contact's name in the body.

The two toggles give four practical combinations.

Which setting should you pick?

Pick the audience by asking three questions about the customer record, in order.

1. Does anyone other than the primary contact need to see this email? If no, primary contact only.
2. If yes, should they see each other's replies? If yes, all contacts on one shared email.
3. If no, or if personalisation matters, all contacts, separate emails.

Paidnice customers see eight in ten invoices paid on time, and cut overdue invoices by 70% in their first 30 days, once their reminder cadence is dialled in. A good reminder ladder is the schedule, the words, and who gets the email. The wrong audience makes the right message feel pushy, and the right audience makes a firm reminder feel routine.

For the full picture of what Xero's reminder schedule does and doesn't cover, see Xero invoice reminders: how they work, and where they stop.

Common questions

Whose name goes in the email body when I'm sending separate emails?

In Paidnice, the body greets the contact the email is sent to. Each separate email reads as if it were written for that contact.

Whose name goes in the email body on the shared, one-email setup?

The primary contact's name. The other contacts are visible on the To line.

Can I exclude a specific contact from all of this?

Yes. Untick the "Include in emails" flag on that contact inside Xero. Paidnice respects it across every audience setting.

Will recipients see each other's email addresses on the shared email?

Yes. They are on the To line, visible to all recipients. If every contact should receive the reminder without seeing the others, use separate emails, or pair primary-contact-only with the CC field on a sender profile for internal stakeholders.

Why does Xero send reminders to the wrong contact?

Because Xero sends to the contact record, not to whoever you emailed the invoice to. If a project manager received the invoice and accounts payable is not on the record with "Include in emails" ticked, the reminder misses them. See routing Xero reminders to a different department.

Close the gap, with the right audience every time

Picking the audience pattern takes about a minute. Decide which combination fits your customer base, set the two toggles in Email Preferences, and override per policy where you need different behaviour.

Signing up to Paidnice is free, with no credit card needed, and there is a one-click install on the Xero App Store. You do not need to migrate anything. Paidnice reads your existing Xero data and starts closing the gap between invoice and payment from the next reminder onwards.

Install Paidnice from the Xero App Store →

Written by

Denym Bird

Co-founder & CEO of Paidnice

Denym is a software entrepreneur and writes about accounts receivables management for small business.

LinkedIn X