Can you change the reply-to address on Xero invoice reminders?

Written by

Denym Bird Denym BirdCo-founder & CEO of Paidnice Denym started Paidnice in 2022 after customers paying late left his own business short on payroll. He has led it to $1 billion collected on time across more than 1 million invoices, and writes about credit control, late fees and getting paid on Xero and QuickBooks. Personally tested

Co-founder & CEO of Paidnice

Denym tested where Xero reminder replies land, covering the default login email of whoever first switched reminders on and why it can only change to another Xero user.

Denym Bird
Reviewed by Jack Daffron Jack DaffronCo-founder of Paidnice Jack is a co-founder of Paidnice and has built accounting software for more than 10 years. He builds the product that sends reminders, adds late fees and takes payments for businesses on Xero, QuickBooks and ERPs such as NetSuite and Business Central.

Co-founder of Paidnice

Updated Nov 9, 2026 · 6 min

Summary

Yes, you can change the reply-to address on Xero invoice reminders. By default every reply goes to the login email of the user who first turned reminders on. In the Sales menu open Invoices, click Invoice Reminders, and pick a different address under Send replies to. One address covers the whole organisation.

  • The default: Xero Central states that customer replies go to the login email of the person that first turns reminders on, and that the address can be edited.
  • The limit: The choice is restricted to your existing Xero users' addresses, and it applies to every reminder in the organisation, so replies cannot land with a different person per customer.
  • Xero's position: A request to default the reply-to to the logged-in user was posted on 17 April 2026, holds 3 votes at Gaining Support, and Xero replied on 11 June 2026 that it will monitor demand.
Contents▾

Where do replies to Xero invoice reminders go by default?

Replies to Xero invoice reminders go to the login email of the user who first turned invoice reminders on for the Xero organisation, whoever set up the reminder and whichever customer it went to.

Xero's setup article puts it in one line: any customer replies go to the login email of the person that first turns reminders on, and you can edit this address. Nothing about the invoice, the customer or the user who edited the reminder wording changes that. The address is set once, when the feature is switched on, and stays until someone changes it.

That is why a "can we have a copy of the invoice" reply from a customer can land with a director who enabled reminders during setup two years ago, or with the bookkeeper who did the Xero migration and has since moved on, while the credit controller who chases the account never sees it.

Free: Payment reminder email templatesCopy the reminder emails for before, on and after the due date.

How do you change the reply-to address on Xero invoice reminders?

You change the reply-to address on Xero invoice reminders from the Invoice Reminders screen under Sales, using the Send replies to field. The change applies to every reminder in the organisation at once.

  1. Open the Sales menu and select Invoices.
  2. Click Invoice Reminders at the top of the invoices list. You need the Standard or Adviser role to see it.
  3. Find Send replies to. Xero's article on editing reminders lists it under the settings that apply to all reminders.
  4. Select the address you want replies sent to. The list holds the email addresses of the users on your Xero organisation.
  5. Click Save. Replies to every reminder sent from this point go to the new address. Replies to reminders already sent go to the old one.

If the address you want is not in the list, invite that mailbox as a Xero user first. A shared inbox such as accounts@ has to be a user before it can be the reply-to.

What can't Xero do with reminder replies?

Xero cannot send reminder replies to a different address per customer, per department, per invoice or per team member, and cannot use an address that is not a Xero user. One reply-to covers every reminder the organisation sends.

That leaves three gaps. A business with two credit controllers who split the ledger cannot route each controller's replies back to them. A company that invoices several departments at one customer cannot send Marketing's replies to the account manager for Marketing. And a mailbox that nobody logs into Xero with, such as a ticketing address, cannot be chosen at all.

Xero's product ideas board holds a live request on exactly this. "Invoice reminder - Reply to Email Default to Logged In User" asks Xero to set the reply-to to whichever user sends the reminder rather than the subscriber. It was posted on 17 April 2026, holds 3 votes and sits at Gaining Support. Xero replied on 11 June 2026 that it will continue to monitor feedback from the community and gauge the demand. The older and larger thread, "Ability to change invoice reminder to different email address", posted 12 May 2022 with 84 votes, is about who receives the reminder rather than where replies go, and is covered in why Xero invoice reminders go to the wrong person.

A related request, "Invoice reminders - Option to send copy to self", asks Xero to copy each reminder to the sender. It was posted on 12 January 2023, holds 62 votes and shows Under review, with Xero's last reply on 17 April 2025 saying research into the future of invoice reminders had begun. Until then, the only record of what a customer was sent is the reminder history on the invoice.

What should the reply-to be when the person who turned reminders on has left?

When the user who turned reminders on has left, set Send replies to on a monitored shared inbox that is a Xero user, such as accounts@ or ar@, rather than the next person's personal login.

A personal address moves the same problem to the next leaver. A shared inbox that the whole finance team reads survives holidays and resignations, and it keeps the customer's reply in the place where the person who can act on it will find it. Give the inbox its own Xero login, then select it under Send replies to.

The same choice matters when reminders are on for several customers with different account managers. With one address for the organisation, the shared inbox is the only setting that reaches everyone. The split by customer that the account managers want is in sending Xero invoice reminders to different departments at one customer.

How does Paidnice route reminder replies?

Paidnice sets the Reply-To on each sender profile, and each reminder, statement, late fee and early payment discount policy picks its own sender profile. One organisation can send replies to as many addresses as it has policies.

A sender profile holds a From Name, From Email, Reply-To and BCC. You can create as many as you need, set one as the default, and override the profile on a one-off manual send. The pattern most teams use is a ladder: accounts@ on the due date, a named credit controller at 7 to 14 days, then a director at 21 days and on late fees, each with replies returning to the person whose name is on the email.

On the Pro plan Paidnice invoice reminders for Xero send from your own domain. You verify the domain once, and after that any address on it works as a From or Reply-To without further setup or an extra mailbox licence. The BCC field takes any address, including a CRM logging address, so a copy of every reminder lands in your CRM or the team inbox without a Xero user behind it. Sign-up is free, the first 20 actions are free and no card is needed.

Replies come back to a shared inbox

Replies to Paidnice reminders also come back into Conversations, the shared inbox in Paidnice, matched to the customer and the invoice. Email and SMS replies sit in one list with unread counts. Each one can be assigned to a person, answered by email or SMS, and marked resolved when it is done.

Paidnice Conversations list filtered to Open, with replies such as Already paid last week and Paying this today, sorry for the delay

Before this, we saw teams build it themselves. One set the reply-to to the bookkeeper, added a BCC and wrote an inbox filter to archive the copies.

Another ran collections from a Gmail shared inbox with labels and stars. With the shared inbox for reminder replies, the whole team sees what the customer wrote, and nobody needs a Xero login for it.

Paidnice sender profile: from WellPaid co. at accounts@wellpaid.co, reply-to credit@wellpaid.co
Replies go to the reply-to address you set.

Common questions

Does changing the reply-to change who the reminder comes from?
No. Send replies to only decides where a customer's reply lands. The From address and sender name on Xero reminders are set by Xero's email service, and you cannot change them from the Invoice Reminders screen.

Can Xero send reminder replies to two people?
No. Send replies to holds one address. To reach two people, use a shared inbox or a distribution group that is set up as a Xero user and forwards to both.

Can I get a copy of every reminder Xero sends?
Not today. The request "Invoice reminders - Option to send copy to self" holds 62 votes and is Under review on Xero's product ideas board. The sent date and status of each reminder are on the invoice's reminder history.

Where do replies to Paidnice reminders go?
Into Conversations, the shared inbox in Paidnice, matched to the customer and the invoice, on every plan. Assign each reply to an owner, reply by email or SMS, and add internal notes the customer cannot see.

Does the reply-to address need to be a Xero user?
Yes. The Send replies to list only offers the email addresses of users on the Xero organisation, so invite the mailbox as a user before you can select it.

Paidnice features in this article

Share this post

About the editorial team

Written by Denym Bird Co-founder & CEO of Paidnice

Denym started Paidnice in 2022 after customers paying late left his own business short on payroll. He has led it to $1 billion collected on time across more than 1 million invoices, and writes about credit control, late fees and getting paid on Xero and QuickBooks.

Reviewed by Jack Daffron Co-founder of Paidnice

Jack is a co-founder of Paidnice and has built accounting software for more than 10 years. He builds the product that sends reminders, adds late fees and takes payments for businesses on Xero, QuickBooks and ERPs such as NetSuite and Business Central.

Paidnice features in this article

Try Our Free Accounts Receivable Calculators

Optimize your cash flow with our suite of financial tools designed for AR professionals. Calculate DSO, aging analysis, late fees, and more.

Explore Calculators

Start getting paid on time with Paidnice

Connect Xero or QuickBooks and Paidnice prepares draft policies for you. Nothing runs until you approve them.

Rated 5 stars, 160+ reviews · Xero App of the Year